When confronted by Michael, Stephen confessed he was worried that he hadn't found a "sexual spark" with Michael yet. He admitted that having had an "instant attraction to someone [else]" was a "lightbulb moment" for him, realising that their relationship was more of a "friendship."
It certainly seems like the two men could remain friends, particularly as they share similar family values.
"I need a man who wants a family, who loves his family, who is here for love," Michael said upon entering the experiment.
Originally from Ohio, USA, the salesperson now resides in Melbourne.
Having been single for five years, the 34-year-old explained that he is tired of the inconsistency of dating and is ready to settle down.
In a similar circumstance, Stephen came into the experiment having been single for four years after his ex cheated on him.
The Perth-based groom values serious and monogamous relationships, explaining upon entering that he "wants a man who is family orientated with a good sense of humour and killer smile".
Both valuing family, Stephen was delighted to learn that his new spouse was a sperm donor for his friends, Nathalie and Nicole, so they could have children of their own.
"It takes a pretty special person to be able to do that," Stephen said. "That's a huge tick in my box."
The first bump in the road came when Michael revealed that Stephen was not his first match, and that his original groom pulled out of the experiment.
"Instantly I felt sick," said the 26-year-old. "I felt like this is not a genuine match; this is a really last minute, slap dash, you'll do. That's a red flag. Am I just his fill in?"
Want romance without the reality TV drama? Sign up for eharmony today!