According to The Dail Mail, 31-year-old Brittany has doubts: "Look, I'm sure that what Brooke is saying, she honestly believes."
Brittany then continued: "I wasn't there at that time but I was told something different.
"There's no point in bringing it up. I would personally never go into it but Soph and I were told something very different."
So who's lying to who?
Brooke revealed on Bachelor in Paradise that the ex-Wallaby was not planning on choosing a girl at the end:
"My last date with Nick, we were on a motorbike. I thought maybe I would be the girl at the end, but he stopped the cameras and smothered his mic to tell me that he wasn’t gonna pick anyone in the end."
According to The Daily Mail, the time this confession occurred was during episode seven of the series, when at least 12 women remained vying for Nick's heart.
Should Brooke have said something?