NewIdea
  • Royals
  • Celebrity
  • News
  • Beauty & Style
  • Health & Wellbeing
  • Travel
  • Home & Away
  • Podcasts
  • Win
  • Video
NewIdea
  • Royals
  • Celebrity
  • News
  • Beauty & Style
  • Health & Wellbeing
  • Travel
  • Home & Away
  • Podcasts
  • Win
  • Video
Subscribe
Home and Away opening title
Watch 1:09

Home and Away opening title

{headline}

{headline}

The Block’s Shelley Craft breaks down in tears amid emotional revelation

The Block’s Shelley Craft breaks down in tears amid emotional revelation

The Block: Scott Cam and Shelley Craft 'quitting show'

The Block: Scott Cam and Shelley Craft 'quitting show'

The Block Sara personally abuses judge Neale Whitaker

The Block winner LEAKED

The Block winner LEAKED

{headline}

{headline}

The Block winners were already millionaires

The Block winners were already millionaires

The Block winners Tess and Luke say their time on show was "tough"

The Block winners Tess and Luke say their time on show was "tough"

The Block’s Jesse and Mel “public toilet” comment shocks fan

The Block’s Jesse and Mel “public toilet” comment shocks fan

{headline}

{headline}

Scott Cam explodes: ‘Don’t lie to me!’

Scott Cam explodes: ‘Don’t lie to me!’

TV meltdown: The Block rocked by cheating scandal

TV meltdown: The Block rocked by cheating scandal

The Block scandal: Mitch and Mark blast Mel for 'stealing' designs

The Block scandal: Mitch and Mark blast Mel for 'stealing' designs

The Block's Jess responds to baby rumours

The Block's Sara and Hayden announce gender of second child

The Block's Dan fires back at villain Sara

The Block's Sara: The Bachelor girls get bullied less than us

  1. Home
  2. The Block

The Block: Judge Darren Palmer lashes back after being blasted over Mitch and Mark

It's the increasingly fraught controversy that just won't go away
  • 10 Sep 2019

Openly gay The Block judge Darren Palmer has faced off with critics on Twitter, in the wake of the perceived homophobia scandal that has torn the show this week.

Following bitter clashes between host Scott Cam and gay contestants Mitch and Mark over judgements they felt were tinged with negative stereotypes about gay people, Darren has been fielding questions about the matter on social media – including a number of hostile accusations about the show.

WATCH: Scott Cam storms off after Mitch and Mark fail to apologise on The Block

‘Did Scotty miss that Mitch and Mark feel certain remarks are very subtle homophobia?’ one fan asked Darren.

‘Scott doesn’t judge so they’re not his remarks,’ Darren said of the judgements that upset the couple.

‘2 out of 3 of [the judges] are gay. The other one has gay people who she loves very dearly. None of us are homophobic. We judge on what we see and when the game is changed one week where the master bedroom becomes a living space, some weeks that decision will work for Mitch and Mark, some weeks it will work against them.’

Questioned further on whether Mitch and Mark have been unfairly tarred with accusations they are building a wild party house that could upset neighbours – which some see as playing into tired old stereotypes about gay people – Darren insisted that was not the case.

‘Any couple that changed the flow of rooms to affect the game and other homes [would be judged the same way],’ he tweeted. ‘Let’s not forget we judge on what we see and we saw Mitch & Mark put a bar in their top floor room.’

But some fans were not having it. Noting that The Block is widely perceived to have an extremely poor record with casting diverse contestants, one fan suggested to Darren that this week's unpleasant drama was one of Nine’s own making.  

Darren Palmer on Twitter

‘This is very confusing- the brand #theblock and @Channel9 have always been seen as a little homophobic & at times racist,’ wrote viewer Ross.

‘Don’t treat the audience as fools. We see. We hear. We know everyone is doing their job for the brand.’

Replied Darren: ‘Don’t be confused. My words are clear and they speak for themselves. I’m not homophobic. I’m gay.

‘I’m not sure what else is needed to be clearer. We judge finished rooms. We don’t know the contestants. We’re not judging personalities. We don’t get to see personalities.’

Darren then retweeted an earlier argument he’d had online about Mitch and Mark, that also related to complaints about the show's treatment of its rare gay contestants.

Writing that he has always defended ‘Mitch and Mark’s valid and earned place on The Block’, Darren was referencing an earlier social media controversy over the way the men have been depicted on the show.

Amid some sharp Twitter criticism at the time from New Idea’s own Matt Denby that The Block was seemingly only interested in casting gay male contestants as ‘cartoonish comedy figures or bitchy antagonists,’ Darren stepped in to defend the show, which Matt had not even named at that point.

He replied that he feels the show has a good record with the portrayal of gay people - nominating himself and fellow judge Neale Whitaker as balance to Mitch and Mark. Darren further claimed the show is great for the gay community.

‘Our community has so many diverse kinds of people, Neale & I represent other facets,’ he wrote. ‘Seeing different types of people represented on our screens is positive.

‘With 2/3rds of the judges being gay & a large amount of people behind the scenes the block does a lot for our community.’

But Matt wasn’t having it, highlighting The Block’s record with contestants.

WATCH: Mitch and Mark lash out at Scott Cam on The Block

‘Thanks to you and Neale for the great job you do, but casting of contestants is another matter,’ he responded.

‘Australian reality TV has a problem in this regard, and that’s widely recognised. The days of gay people being given space only if they perform as the clown or the bitch are over.’

Darren responded by saying that was his point, adding, ‘I’ve worked on tv as a contestant & judge for 10 years & was not cast as the clown.

‘Diversity is worthwhile. No personality types are less than. To criticise someone for being themselves is the opposite of the what we as a community need.’

Matt clapped back at the judge for his representation of his views, clarifying that he was not criticising Mitch and Mark, but was rather highlighting how Aussie reality TV seems to disproportionately cast gay male contestants to play certain pre-determined characters.

‘I haven’t criticised [Mitch and Mark] and I won’t criticise them,’ he told Darren. ‘I’m criticising the casting process that consistently shoehorns gay men into those limited roles.’

Mitch and Mark are experienced house flippers who have renovated 15 properties and previously starred on another reality show, Aussie Property Flippers.

The Block

Tenson is exploding on The Block

Channel Nine

The drama began when the couple deemed Scott's words about their living room ‘inappropriate and offensive,’ after Cam referred to the space as their ‘party room.’

The host said that the judges noted a competing team had placed their second master bedroom on level two, ‘considering the party room on top of Mitch and Mark’s house,’ which left the men unamused.

When Scott compared their work with the other team, who has adjusted their plans "to get away from the noisy people in your place," Mark lashed out.

‘There’s no noisy people. People need to cope with the fact that there are multiple living spaces in all metropolitan homes and they need to actually step away from it because they have no idea,’ he argued, holding up his hand in protest.

As Mitch stood glowering on by his partner's side, he continued:’"It is a living space as any house in any suburban part of Australia has. And if they’re making a judgment about us — because they’ve often said, “People like us” — I need to understand what does that mean? Are you judging us?’

Things have continued to escalate since then, with further confrontations milked in a series of promos for future episodes.

However it all works out, one thing is for sure – The Block continues to have a major diversity problem, and that can’t be papered over like a dodgy TV renovation.

WATCH: Meet The Block's Mitch and Mark

  • TV
  • The Block
  • Reality TV

Just $6 for 6 issues delivered!-SAVE 79%

Subscribe to New Idea today

Subscribe Now
Just $6 for 6 issues delivered!

Just $6 for 6 issues delivered!-SAVE 79%

Subscribe to New Idea today

Subscribe Now
Just $6 for 6 issues delivered!

Recommended to you

Home and Away opening title
Watch 1:09

Home and Away opening title

{headline}

{headline}

The Block’s Shelley Craft breaks down in tears amid emotional revelation

The Block’s Shelley Craft breaks down in tears amid emotional revelation

The Block: Scott Cam and Shelley Craft 'quitting show'

The Block: Scott Cam and Shelley Craft 'quitting show'

The Block Sara personally abuses judge Neale Whitaker

The Block winner LEAKED

The Block winner LEAKED

{headline}

{headline}

The Block winners were already millionaires

The Block winners were already millionaires

The Block winners Tess and Luke say their time on show was "tough"

The Block winners Tess and Luke say their time on show was "tough"

The Block’s Jesse and Mel “public toilet” comment shocks fan

The Block’s Jesse and Mel “public toilet” comment shocks fan

{headline}

{headline}

Scott Cam explodes: ‘Don’t lie to me!’

Scott Cam explodes: ‘Don’t lie to me!’

TV meltdown: The Block rocked by cheating scandal

TV meltdown: The Block rocked by cheating scandal

The Block scandal: Mitch and Mark blast Mel for 'stealing' designs

The Block scandal: Mitch and Mark blast Mel for 'stealing' designs

The Block's Jess responds to baby rumours

The Block's Sara and Hayden announce gender of second child

The Block's Dan fires back at villain Sara

The Block's Sara: The Bachelor girls get bullied less than us

NewIdea
  • About Us
  • Subscribe Today
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Competitions
NewIdea Magazine Subscribe
  • About Us
  • Subscribe Today
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Competitions

Brands

  • Girlfriend
  • New Idea food
  • Practical Parenting
  • That’s Life
  • Who

Our Network

  • Better Homes and Gardens
  • BHG Shop
  • marie claire
  • Instyle
  • Beauty Crew
  • Women's Weekly Food
  • Bounty Parents
  • Home Beautiful
  • All Recipes
  • Perth Now
  • The West Australian
  • 7Plus
  • Airtasker
  • 7NEWS
  • SocietyOne
  • Health Engine
  • Starts at 60
© 2021 Are Media PTY LTD
Get more from New Idea

Magazine Subscription Offer

Just $6 for 6 issues delivered!-SAVE 79%

Shop This Offer
Just $6 for 6 issues delivered!