"To help us remember this experience, I’m going to give you the ugliest ring known to mankind..." one angry fan wrote on Twitter, while another exclaimed, "Even Carlin's ring is boring! Come on dude wtf."
Even though Carlin was the favorite to win, fans were still in shock that Angie dumped lovable larrikin Timm Hanly during the finale, leaving the fireproofer from Melbourne heartbroken.
Speaking 10 Daily, Timm revealed that he was convinced he would be the winner admitting he was absolutely shocked with the outcome of the show.
"I deadset thought 100 per cent that I was going to win, that I was going to be ending up with her," the 27-year-old told 10 Daily.
"When I first went in there I went in with an open mind, I actually didn't think it would happen. Next thing I know I was swept off my feet."
Timm continued: "It took me a fair while to process what actually happened and then you don't see her again. You have this whole experience together and I haven't seen her again, do you know what I mean? It's f*cking heavy."
WATCH: Timm Hanly left heartbroken after Angie dumps him for Carlin