According to the Daily Mail, other fans of the cooking show argued that it was just her bra.
Either way, Karito and Ian suffered a disastrous night in the kitchen, plummeting to the bottom of the leaderboard with just 38 points out of 130.
The couple aimed to show off the flavours of colourful Colombia, but missed the mark with all three courses, leaving judges Manu and Pete unimpressed.
"Something went very wrong".
RELATED VIDEO: My Kitchen Rules 2019 celebrity doppelgangers
Catch up on the latest My Kitchen Rules episodes on 7plus