It was the moment MasterChef fans had been waiting all week for with the show’s promos teasing the “greatest dish ever.”
Just moments into last night’s whimsical immunity pin challenge, however, one tiny detail spoiled it all.
WATCH: Reynold unveils his incredible Alice In Wonderland dessert.
Masterchef’s fairy-tale inspired cook off was one of the most magical episodes of the season, gifting us some intricate and beautiful dishes.
While it didn’t fail to enchant the judges, many eagle-eyed fans were left disappointed, spotting a small detail which spoiled the outcome of the challenge.
In this week’s promos for the show the “greatest dish ever” was clearly displayed in a speckled dish. So, when Reynold placed the same bowl on his bench top very early on in the cook, fans were quick to notice.

“Unless multiple people use the same serveware, we’re going to find out who made the famous “best dish ever” as soon as they start plating. Too many ad spoilers this year!” one Twitter user wrote.
“Reynold’s bowl looks like the winner from the ad,” another commented.
With a third also noting: “The Reynold bowl is a bit of a giveaway.”

Even with many fans realising the winning dish had been ruined; the actual unveiling of Reynold’s dish was still something to behold.
Plating up an Alice In Wonderland inspired dessert, Reynold created a theatrical dish comprised of caramelised white chocolate diplomat, pistachio sponge, matcha crumble, dark chocolate and vanilla caramel.

Naming it ‘Down the rabbit hole’ the magic was served when Reynold poured his hot caramel over the base of the dish to melt the chocolate and create a rabbit hole.
The judges were spellbound.
“We asked for fairy tale and if that’s not fairy-tale in a bowl, my goodness, it just looks so magical,” judge Melissa Leong commented.
“THAT is special,” Andy added.
Although unsurprising, the deliberation was unanimous with Reynold earning himself the immunity pin.